It won't decide the whole scorecard, but it's the single biggest real difference between these two ships.
The 30-second answer
A genuinely even category split — two wins each, three ties — that still resolves to a real, if marginal, overall winner.
The scorecard, head to head
Both ships' locked Seabound Dining Scores, all seven categories, exact published figures — nothing here is re-derived. Language is proportional to the gap: 0.0 is a tie, 0.1–0.2 is a marginal edge, 0.3–0.5 is meaningful, 0.6+ is decisive.
Wish Class carries no Suite / Restricted Dining category — the other seven categories redistribute the full weight between them. Category scores are ecosystem judgments from each ship's own scoring pass, never derived from venue arithmetic — which is how a genuinely even 2-2-3 category split still resolves to a clear overall winner once each win's actual gap width is weighed in.
Seven of ten venues, unchanged hull to hull
The Wish-Class core menu, identical on both ships — and for the first time in this trio, the same scored roster size too, with a one-for-one functional counterpart for every venue.
Enchanté. Palo Steakhouse. Worlds of Marvel. 1923. Mickey & Friends Festival of Foods. Marceline Market. Room Service. Seven venues, and every one of them publishes the identical score on Treasure and on Destiny. This is the Wish-Class core, and it travels unchanged from hull to hull — the same pattern as every matchup in this trio.
What's different here: unlike either Wish matchup, neither Treasure nor Destiny carries a scored venue the other lacks. Ten tracked venues each, a counterpart for every one. Where the two ships genuinely differ is the class's two remaining variation points — each ship's third rotational room (Plaza de Coco on Treasure, Pride Lands on Destiny) and each ship's paid casual pub (Periscope Pub vs. Cask & Cannon) — plus a sweets counter that ties exactly at 6.9 despite carrying two different names. That parity holds for this project's scored data specifically: Disney's current official site also lists Wheezy's Freezies, otherwise scored only on Wish, across Treasure and Destiny, but this project doesn't yet carry a score for it on either ship, so it isn't reflected in the roster counts here.
Destiny's two category wins and Treasure's two aren't coming from one ship simply carrying more venues — the roster count matches exactly. They're coming from real, if narrow, differences within matched venue slots and the broader ecosystem each ship builds around them. The category scores are independent judgments consistent with that; they aren't a recount of the venue table.
Like-for-like venue battles
Ten scored matchups. Eight tie exactly; two differ by a tenth of a point.
| Family | Treasure | Destiny |
|---|---|---|
| Specialty — Experience | Enchanté — 9.0 | Enchanté — 9.0 |
| Specialty — Standard | Palo Steakhouse — 8.7 | Palo Steakhouse — 8.7 |
| Included, full service — third rotational room | Plaza de Coco — 8.5 | Pride Lands: Feast of The Lion King — 8.7 |
| Included, full service | Worlds of Marvel — 8.4 | Worlds of Marvel — 8.4 |
| Included, full service | 1923 — 7.9 | 1923 — 7.9 |
| Included, casual quick service | Mickey & Friends Festival of Foods — 7.7 | Mickey & Friends Festival of Foods — 7.7 |
| Extra cost, casual pub | Periscope Pub — 7.4 | Cask & Cannon — 7.3 |
| Included, casual | Marceline Market — 7.3 | Marceline Market — 7.3 |
| Included, casual | Room Service — 7.0 | Room Service — 7.0 |
| Extra cost, sweets counter | Jumbeaux's Sweets — 6.9 | Edna À La Mode Sweets — 6.9 |
Neither ship carries a single unique venue the other lacks in this project's scored data — both run a ten-venue roster with a one-for-one counterpart for every entry. The widest gap on this table is the third rotational room, at two tenths of a point in Destiny's favor; everything else ties exactly or differs by a tenth.
Fixed week vs. flexible mix
Different homeports, and a genuinely different approach to sailing length.
Treasure sails from Port Canaveral, Florida — as of August 2026, a fixed 7-night rotation alternating Western Caribbean (Cozumel, Georgetown, Falmouth) and Eastern Caribbean (Tortola, St. Thomas), both ending with a Castaway Cay call. Same week, every time.
Destiny sails from Fort Lauderdale, Florida (Port Everglades) — her only homeport since debuting in November 2025. Her current sailing mix spans 3-night Bahamas, 4-night Bahamas, 5-night Bahamas or Western Caribbean, and 7-night Eastern or Western Caribbean, all confirmed on sale for the back half of 2026.
The practical upshot: Treasure is the predictable booking — you know exactly what week you're getting. Destiny is the flexible one — and only her longer sailings get the full repeat-room benefit Treasure gets on every departure, which tracks with Destiny's Value score sitting a tenth behind Treasure's.
Family, couple & group fit
Families who want the same trip every year: Treasure's fixed 7-night rotation and class-best Value score are built for exactly that.
Travelers who want to pick their trip length: Destiny's 3- to 7-night mix from Fort Lauderdale offers real flexibility — and the narrow overall dining edge, if that matters to you.
Anyone comparing purely on dining: this is close to a coin flip — two category wins each, three ties, and a marginal 0.1-point overall gap. Homeport and sailing structure are the more decisive difference.
Choose Treasure if… Choose Destiny if…
Choose Treasure if…
- You want a fixed 7-night week, the same rotation every sailing
- You want the class's best Value score — every rotational room repeats, every time
- You want the class's only Mexican-themed rotational room (Plaza de Coco)
- You're planning around Port Canaveral as your homeport
- Predictability matters more to your trip than a marginal 0.1-point dining gap
Choose Destiny if…
- You want the newest ship in the class — Destiny debuted in November 2025
- You want the class's highest Included Dining and Special Experiences scores
- You want the single strongest rotational room in the whole class (Pride Lands, 8.7)
- You want flexibility on sailing length — 3, 4, 5 or 7 nights, Bahamas or Caribbean
- You're planning around Fort Lauderdale as your homeport
In practice, that looks like:
A fixed 7-night Eastern/Western Caribbean rotation from Port Canaveral, with the class's best Value score attached — every rotational room repeats, no exceptions, no planning required.
Destiny's 8.3 narrowly beats Treasure's 8.2, on the strength of the class's highest Included Dining and Special Experiences scores. It's a real, if marginal, overall win.
Treasure's Value category is the class high for a reason that has nothing to do with her kitchens — her sailing structure just makes every specialty booking cost less.
Destiny's genuine 3- to 7-night mix from Fort Lauderdale means picking a trip length without switching ships — and she happens to carry the strongest single rotational room in the class, too.
The final verdict
Destiny wins, 8.3 to 8.2, and it's a real if marginal result. The category count is genuinely even — two wins each, three ties — but Destiny's two wins run twice as wide as Treasure's two, which is the entire overall gap.
The venue table backs up how close this is: eight of ten tracked venues tie exactly, neither ship carries a venue the other lacks, and the widest single gap is two tenths of a point.
If you're choosing purely on dining, this one is close enough to call a coin flip. Homeport (Port Canaveral vs. Fort Lauderdale) and sailing structure (fixed 7-night vs. a flexible 3-to-7-night mix) are the differences actually worth deciding on.
Quick answers
Destiny wins overall, but the categories are split evenly. What actually decided this?
Gap width, not category count alone. Both ships win two categories each (Treasure: Variety, Value; Destiny: Included Dining, Special Experiences), with three more tying exactly — a genuinely even split by the numbers. But Destiny's two wins are each 0.2 points wide against Treasure's two at only 0.1 point wide, and Destiny's winning categories also carry somewhat more combined weight (31.6% to 26.3%). Both factors point the same direction, which is why Destiny's 8.3 edges Treasure's 8.2 even though neither ship out-wins the other on category count.
Do either of these ships have a venue the other one doesn't?
No — a first for this trio, at least in this project's scored data. Wheezy's Freezies is scored on Wish at 6.3, with no Treasure or Destiny entry yet in this project's venue database — though Disney's current official site lists Wheezy's fleet-wide, so that's more likely a data gap than a real difference. Between Treasure and Destiny specifically, the scored roster count matches exactly: ten tracked venues each, with a counterpart for every one.
What's actually different between Plaza de Coco and Pride Lands?
They're the same slot in the rotation — each ship's third included, full-service dining-show room — with a different theme. Plaza de Coco (Treasure) is Coco-themed, the only Mexican-themed rotational room in Wish Class; Pride Lands (Destiny) is Lion King-themed with a Berbere-spiced savanna-feast menu, and scores as the single strongest rotational room in the whole class at 8.7. It's the widest single venue-level gap in this matchup, at two tenths of a point.
Where are these two ships actually sailing right now?
Different ports and different sailing structures. As of August 2026, Treasure sails from Port Canaveral, Florida, on a fixed 7-night Eastern/Western Caribbean rotation. Destiny sails from Fort Lauderdale, Florida (Port Everglades) — her only homeport since debuting in November 2025 — running a genuine mix of 3-night Bahamas, 4-night Bahamas, 5-night Bahamas or Western Caribbean, and 7-night Eastern/Western Caribbean sailings. If you want a fixed week every time, Treasure is the more predictable booking; if you want flexibility on trip length, Destiny offers more of it.
Still torn?
Tell us about your trip.
Your dates, your homeport preference and whether you want a fixed week or flexible length — and we'll tell you which of these two ships fits.
Assistant integration coming soon · answers will always be verified against current pricing before you book.