My wife and I were having dinner at Palomar on Norwegian Aqua when a gentleman at the next table told us he had just gotten off Norwegian Getaway, and the food was practically inedible.
My wife and I looked at each other. We had sailed Getaway three times, in 2014, 2016 and 2023. Neither of us remembered it being a culinary disaster.
Getaway had been his first Norwegian cruise. He’d enjoyed the food on MSC, and he thought the food on Aqua was far better than what he’d had on Getaway. He was actively enjoying a great dinner on one Norwegian ship while telling us how terrible the food was on another.
The more I thought about it, the more I realized I was weighing his fresh, opinionated review against meals I had eaten as long as three years ago.
When we got home, a four-night Getaway sailing out of Port Canaveral caught my eye, and I booked it. My wife and I had already taken three cruises in about a month, and she couldn’t take any more time off work. So I asked Jaxon to go with me.
We have cruised together plenty of times, but this was the first time it would be just the two of us. We joke that he wants to be an only child. He loves having all the attention, and in a chaotic family of seven, he rarely gets it for very long. Crowds can be overwhelming for him, and he thrives when it’s one-on-one and we can move at his pace.
I was curious about the food. I was far more curious about what four days of just us would be like.
Embarkation Day: O’Sheehan’s Was the Right Call
I refused to brave the buffet as soon as we boarded. Jaxon doesn’t do well surrounded by a frantic crowd, and the competitive sport of embarkation-day buffet lunch is too much for me, too. So we went to O’Sheehan’s, sat down, and let somebody bring us our food.
I ordered nachos. He ordered pretzel bites. He made the better call. For our mains, he had a hot dog and fries, and I had a chicken salad sandwich because I didn’t want anything heavy. It was exactly what you would expect from a chain Irish pub: fine, average, and perfectly acceptable for what we needed it to be.
Dinner in the main dining room was a definite step up. He loved his ravioli appetizer and finished his New York strip, followed by chocolate lava cake. I had a shrimp cake that tasted fresh and held together exactly the way it should, followed by a salad and shrimp pasta. I enjoyed the meal. I didn’t know yet that I’d be fondly remembering that shrimp cake the next night for a very different reason.
Sea Day: Cagney’s Got the Steaks Right, Eventually
We ate breakfast and lunch in the main dining room. Both meals got the job done. For dinner, we went to Cagney’s because Jaxon loves steak. He ordered shrimp cocktail and a medium-rare ribeye. I ordered the crab cake and a medium-rare filet.
The crab cake was the first thing I ate on Getaway that I’d call bad. It was mushy and wet, and I left most of it. If you know me, leaving a crab cake on a plate says quite a bit. The complimentary shrimp cake in the main dining room the night before was miles better than the upcharge crab cake.
Then two filets came out. I politely asked about the missing ribeye, and they whisked one back to the kitchen. We would have eaten the two filets just fine, but we had ordered two different cuts and I wanted to write about both. I cut up the filet that was still on the table and handed it to him so he wouldn’t have to wait. He liked it enough that he didn’t offer me a single bite. So that is the entire extent of my filet review.
The ribeye eventually arrived thinner than I expected, with a thick, charred crust. Both steaks were cooked to the exact temperature we ordered. The odd part was that my first bite of ribeye took my brain straight to a Burger King Whopper. I haven’t eaten at Burger King in over a decade, so apparently that is a core memory you simply do not lose.
Dessert was the one part we both agreed on. I had the OMG Cheesecake, he had the seven-layer chocolate cake, and neither of us spoke until the plates were empty.
The Buffet Failed, But the Main Dining Room Delivered
The next morning we retreated to O’Sheehan’s. It was quicker than the main dining room, and we still got table service. Jaxon had scrambled eggs, plain pancakes and yogurt, which is exactly what he demands for breakfast at home. I ordered the same breakfast sandwich I’d had on Aqua and forgot to ask for an over-hard egg. I hate being the guy who modifies the order, but I liked it much better on Aqua when I remembered to ask.
We finally braved the buffet for lunch. I left several things on my plate unfinished. Even the Indian food disappointed me, and that is usually my safest, most reliable bet on any cruise buffet. I have had some spectacular Indian food on ships, but what I tried that day wasn’t up to it. That was the only lunch we ate at the buffet.
That night in the main dining room, he confidently ordered the ravioli again. Of course he did. He had liked it the first time, and he ate all of his pasta entrée, too.
I had an appetizer of short ribs that fell right off the bone, paired with rice-paper rolls and fish sauce. The rolls reminded me of the Vietnamese fried rolls I love, even though these weren’t fried. The short ribs were seasoned flawlessly. I told our server how much I liked it, and he brought me a second plate.
It was the best thing I ate all trip, and I would have been much happier with a third plate of ribs than with the bang bang shrimp I ordered for my main course.
The Last Day: Forgettable Lunch, Fun Dinner
We grabbed a quick breakfast in the main dining room, then tried the American Diner for lunch. My burger tasted like something I could have scooped up at the buffet. Jaxon’s spaghetti and meatballs didn’t look particularly exciting, but he ate it without complaint.
For our final dinner, we both ordered steak and shrimp at Teppanyaki. The food was decent. The chef was entertaining enough that I would happily do that dinner with him again. After a few days of carefully paying attention to what was on the plate, it was really nice to just spend a meal laughing together.
We walked off the ship the next morning, so I skipped breakfast. I did run up to the buffet one last time to secure his required scrambled eggs, plain pancakes and yogurt. He ate them in the room while we packed. The buffet and I ended the trip on reasonably good terms.
What I Would Order Again
If I were repeating this exact Getaway sailing with Jaxon, my dining plan would be short:
O’Sheehan’s
Embarkation-day lunch, and a quicker breakfast with table service. Fine, average, and exactly what we needed.
The main dining room
Most of our dinners. If the short ribs are on the menu, order two from the very start.
Teppanyaki
Decent steak and shrimp, and a chef entertaining enough to make it the loud, fun night out.
Cagney’s
Both steaks came out at the temperature we ordered, and the OMG Cheesecake was worth the visit. Skip the crab cake.
The buffet at lunch
I left several things unfinished, even the Indian food. Use it for a quick breakfast pickup, and the American Diner burger was no improvement.
So, Was the Food Really That Bad?
On our sailing, absolutely not. Most of it was totally fine, a few things were really good, and a handful of items I wouldn’t order again if you paid me.
The Aqua passenger’s comparison made perfect sense to me after eating on both ships so close together. I ate better on Aqua, and I could see why he noticed the difference. Even the basic breakfast sandwich I ordered on both ships gave me a clear favorite, though I will take the blame for forgetting to specify my egg preference on Getaway.
One caution on numbers. Our Norwegian Getaway dining guide scores her 8.2 across all 19 venues, a read on how much she offers and how well it’s spread across the ship. This entry is one sailing’s plates, so treat the two as different questions.
If I were doing this exact Getaway sailing again with Jaxon, I’d go straight to O’Sheehan’s on embarkation day, give the main dining room the vast majority of our dinners, and pick Teppanyaki for a loud, fun night out together. I’d leave the buffet strictly for a quick morning breakfast pickup. And if those short ribs were on the menu again, I’d order two from the very start.
I went back to Getaway because a stranger at dinner made me curious. I came home with a solid answer about the food, a pretty good idea of what Jaxon would order if we went back tomorrow, and a photo of the two of us on a sunny day at Great Stirrup Cay.
That is the part of the trip I want to write about next.
A day at Great Stirrup Cay, just the two of us
The sunny day from the photo, and what an only-child afternoon looks like when it finally happens.
Series · Norwegian Getaway 2026 · entry 12
More from the Logbook, and the guides behind it
Norwegian Aqua Dining Review: Palomar Stole the Show, and My Wife Ordered Better Than I Did
The dinner where a stranger said the Getaway food was inedible, and what we ate on Aqua instead.
Norwegian Aqua 2026 · Entry 11Norwegian Aqua First Impressions: Standout Menus, Stellar Shows, and a Labyrinth I’m Still Learning
The ship I was comparing Getaway against.
Dining GuideNorwegian Getaway Dining, Scored
All 19 venues, with the Seabound Dining Score.
Ship GuideNorwegian Getaway
The complete guide to the ship we sailed.
Norwegian Getaway 2026 · Entry 13Norwegian Getaway With Jaxon: A Ship and Balcony Cabin Review From Our First Cruise Alone Together
The same sailing from the cabin and the ship, not the plate.
Line GuideNorwegian Cruise Line, Decoded
Which ship fits which kind of traveler.
Port GuideGreat Stirrup Cay
Norwegian’s private island, where the photo was taken.
Sailing From Port CanaveralPort Canaveral Cruises, Decoded
Terminals, parking and the airport run for the port we left from.
I booked and paid for this cruise myself, in full.
Some journeys take you places. Others stay with you forever.Journey further.
