Why Princess Is Trying to Take Care of Everyone at Once

Fifty years ago it sold America a promise on national television. It's been trying to cash that check for everyone on board ever since.

By Joey Boleslawski — founder of Seabound Journeys, CLIA-affiliated travel advisor, and Florida Seller of Travel (Ref. No. ST15578).

⚔ Head to head: Celebrity vs. Princess — the premium showdown →

← Part of the "Built to Solve" series — start with the map

Two of the most famous things Princess Cruises has ever done sit forty years apart and look completely unrelated. In the 1970s, it was The Love Boat — the show that ran for a decade and did more to sell cruising to ordinary Americans than every ad the industry ever bought. In the 2020s, it's the Medallion — a coin-sized wearable that unlocks your cabin as you walk up to it, summons a drink to wherever you're standing, and shows you your travel companions on a map.

One is a feeling; the other is a gadget. But they're the same sentence spoken in two languages: on this ship, someone is paying attention to you.

And that pairing is the key to the whole company, because The Love Boat wasn't just good marketing — it was a debt. Every week, on national television, the fantasy was the same: a ship where the crew know your name, the captain notices you, the romance and the care find you specifically, not the crowd. Princess was the ship in the show. Which means Princess is the one line in this industry that made its core promise to the entire country before most of the country had ever sailed — and has spent fifty years trying to make the real ship live up to the one on TV. Everything Princess builds is an installment payment on a promise it made on television.

The Promise Was Always Rationed

Here's the problem with that promise, and it's worth being precise, because it's the actual engine of this article.

The premium feeling — being personally looked after — is made of exactly two ingredients: attention and availability. Someone has time for you. There's a table for you. And both are brutally scarce on a ship of several thousand people, which is why cruising has always rationed them the only way businesses know how: by price. The attention lived in the suites, welded to an expensive room. The availability lived behind upcharges — the specialty restaurant, the drinks, the Wi-Fi, the reserved seat, each sold à la carte to keep demand thinned to what the ship could actually serve. The base fare got you a bed and a buffet. The thing that made a premium line feel premium was, by design, the thing most of its passengers never touched.

Rationing by price wasn't cruelty. It was arithmetic. It was also, if you'd absorbed the Love Boat promise, a quiet betrayal — because on the show, nobody needed a suite to be noticed.

Princess Handed Everyone the Rope

So Princess made the generous bet: stop rationing. Pry the entire premium experience loose from the price of the room and let anyone claim it. Its packages — Plus, and the all-in Premier — fold the drinks, the Wi-Fi, the gratuities, the unlimited specialty dining, the reserved seating, the shore-excursion credit into the fare, and you can buy them from any cabin on the ship. Book the cheapest interior stateroom and eat at the steakhouse every night with a cocktail in your hand and a saved seat at the show.

The premium experience stopped being something you got by booking up, and became something you simply choose. Readers of this series will recognize the move — it's MSC's Yacht Club insight, unbundling the experience from the real estate, pushed one step further: not a premium enclave you can buy into, but the premium itself, spread across the whole manifest. It's also the closest thing in cruising to my own company's reason for existing. Value was never the square footage. It was being looked after without being nickel-and-dimed — and Princess is the line betting that belongs to everyone, whatever they paid for the room.

The Medallion Is an Attempt to Repeal Scarcity

But un-rationing only solves half the problem. Attention still doesn't scale — a crew member can only know so many names, a bartender can only see so far down the line. Promise personal care to five thousand people and you've promised something a crowd makes physically impossible.

Unless you cheat. The Medallion is Princess trying to cheat — to manufacture attention with technology instead of headcount. The ship recognizes you at your door and it's already unlocked. You order from a lounge chair and a crew member finds you, wherever you've wandered, and hands you your drink with your name attached. The app knows where your family is when you don't. None of that requires a butler who's memorized you; it requires software that has. The Medallion is an attempt to repeal the scarcity of attention — to make a five-thousand-person ship behave as if it noticed you personally. When it works, it's the Love Boat feeling produced industrially: not one crew member who knows you, but a whole ship that acts like it does.

And here's the quiet radical part: everyone gets it. The Medallion isn't a suite perk. The cheapest interior cabin gets the same recognizing doors and the same drink that finds them. Princess digitized the thing the suites used to monopolize.

You Can't Digitize a Steakhouse Table

Now the honest part, and it's not a footnote — it's the second half of the thesis, still unsolved.

Technology repealed the scarcity of attention. It cannot repeal the scarcity of availability, because availability is made of atoms: tables, chairs, chefs, square feet. And when Princess made specialty dining unlimited for every Premier holder, the atoms did what atoms do. The steakhouse that always had a table when dinner was a $39 upcharge now sells out its Friday and Saturday nights completely; guests are told to book sixty days before they sail; and Princess has stood up an around-the-clock telephone hotline — the Dine Line — whose entire job is helping people land the reservations the company already promised them. Sit with that image: a call center, open all night, rationing out the dinners that were included for free. The bars grow lines because everyone's holding the drink package. When you stop rationing by price, you don't end rationing — you just switch to rationing by queue, by sixty-day planning windows, by who's fastest on the app. The currency changed from money to effort.

Princess knows it, and you can watch the tuning happen in public: packages raised and reshuffled for 2026, the least popular cuts walked back within days after guests pushed back, more adjustment surely coming. And the strain runs against the grain of the fleet itself — the newest Sphere-class ships, Sun and Star Princess, are the largest Princess has ever built, which means the promise of feeling personally attended to is being made to more people per hull than ever. The software half of premium is solved. The physical half is still a construction site. None of that means the bet is wrong. It means Princess volunteered for the hardest version of the problem — an all-inclusive that everyone actually uses is a far harder machine to run than one most people leave on the table.

Virgin Answered the Same Question Backwards

Set Princess next to Virgin Voyages, because they're chasing the same all-included dream from opposite ends, and the comparison explains everything about why one strains and the other doesn't. Virgin also folds everything into the fare — but it protects the promise by shrinking the crowd: adults-only, mid-size ships, a deliberately narrow audience, so demand can never swamp the supply. Princess did the reverse: enormous ships, everyone welcome, all-inclusive for all of them at once. Virgin made the all-inclusive easy by keeping most people out. Princess made it hard by letting everyone in. One bought its coherence with exclusion; the other bought its generosity with a capacity problem. Neither is wrong — but it's exactly why a Virgin restaurant is easy to book and a Princess steakhouse on a Saturday is a small military operation.

For the People Who Want to Be Taken Care Of

At Seabound Journeys, I don't sell Princess as finished, and I don't undersell what it's reaching for. I ask what someone's trying to solve. And if the answer is I want to walk on, hand over nothing, decide nothing, and just be looked after — the good dinners, the drink whenever, the ship that seems to know me — without booking the priciest cabin to earn it, then Princess is built around that exact wish, and the Medallion is the closest anyone has come to delivering it at scale. Book your dinners the day the window opens, and know that on a full ship the promise still occasionally outruns the kitchen.

Fifty years ago, a television show promised America that on this particular line, somebody would be paying attention to you — by name, whoever you were, whatever you paid. That was always an outrageous thing to promise several thousand people at once. Princess's whole modern history is the engineering project of keeping it anyway: first unbundling the premium from the suite, then teaching the ship itself to do the noticing. The feeling of being known, they've largely built. The table for everyone who now shows up — that's the part still under construction, and you can hear them working on it, all night, on the Dine Line.

Value comes in all shapes and sizes. Princess's contribution was insisting it shouldn't come only in the shape of a suite.

← All articles