The 30-second answer
Carnival Firenze and her sister Carnival Venezia are Carnival's Venice Class — both ex-Costa hulls (Costa Firenze and Costa Venezia) transferred into the Carnival fleet as the line's first-ever “transfer class.” This is not a tie. Firenze scores 8.2 (weighted 8.155) and Venezia scores 7.9 (weighted 7.940) — a real, modest 0.3-point gap. It shows up in exactly four categories: Included Dining, Variety, Value, and Casual & Quick Dining, every one of them because Firenze carries a deeper complimentary casual roster. The other four categories — Specialty Dining, Quality Ceiling, Special Experiences, and Suite & Restricted Dining — are identical between the two ships.
The dining story here is a genuinely distinctive premium core on top of the deeper of the two included tiers. Michelangelo and Medici anchor two complimentary Main Dining Rooms, alongside Lido Marketplace and eight free quick-service stops — Guy's Burger Joint, Tomodoro (a Mexican-Italian fusion counter filling BlueIguana Cantina's usual slot), La Strada Grill, Il Mercato, Pizzeria del Capitano, Swirls, and two venues genuinely exclusive to this ship: Fresh Creations and Chicken Shack (which shares its physical counter with Seafood Shack rather than running as its own space). Five specialty restaurants carry the same Costa-built identity found across the whole class: Il Viaggio, Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, Bonsai Sushi, Bonsai Teppanyaki, and The Chef's Table.
All of that lands Firenze at 8.2 (weighted 8.155) on the Seabound Dining Score, the higher of the two Venice Class ships. That edge is entirely a casual-bench story — qualifying suite guests get the same real, if modest, breakfast-only Moda Lounge benefit scored 4.3 as Venezia's guests get at Carnevale Lounge, and the two ships' specialty programs are identical down to the dollar. This guide states the reason for the gap plainly rather than either manufacturing a tie or overstating it.
Firenze's story is the same strong premium ceiling as her sister, carried by a genuinely deeper included/casual bench. Book Il Viaggio, Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, or The Chef's Table early if a specific night matters to you — and know before you go that Chicken Shack shares its physical counter with Seafood Shack rather than running as a separate restaurant.
The Seabound Dining Scorecard
Eight categories, each judged on its own merits and weighted to a single score — never averaged up from the 20 venue scores below, because a ship with a wide casual bench shouldn't out-score a ship with a handful of genuinely excellent restaurants, or vice versa.
Specialty Dining reads 8.5, driven by five restaurants that span format as much as cuisine: a regional Italian tasting menu, a steakhouse, a sushi bar, an interactive teppanyaki room, and a hosted tasting experience — the identical bench, at the identical score, carried by Venezia. Quality Ceiling reads 8.6, also identical to Venezia's, because it reads the whole program's best-case meal and that top tier is the one place the two ships are built exactly the same.
Included Dining reads 8.1 and Casual & Quick Dining reads 8.2 — both genuinely the class's higher marks, and both a direct, honest consequence of Firenze's roster being the deeper of the two Venice Class ships. She carries twelve included venues against Venezia's ten: Fresh Creations and Chicken Shack are genuinely exclusive to this ship, and Il Mercato occupies the deli/market slot Venezia fills with Carnival Deli. Variety (8.5) and Value (8.1) lead Venezia's 8.1 and 7.8 for the same reason — more complimentary formats to draw on, not stronger execution of the ones both ships share.
Special Experiences reads 9.0, carried almost entirely by The Chef's Table — a single-driver category, the same convention this project applies wherever one venue's own score effectively sets the category, reinforced here by Bonsai Teppanyaki's interactive tableside format — identical to Venezia's own 9.0. Suite & Restricted Dining reads 4.3, also identical: qualifying suite guests get morning access to the Moda Lounge for a daily select breakfast menu, a real but modest benefit, well short of a full suite restaurant.
What's already included
Twelve of Firenze's 20 venues carry no per-visit charge for the core menu — two Main Dining Rooms, a buffet, eight quick-service stops, and Room Service, complimentary item-by-item with one real exception, and two more included stops than sister ship Venezia carries.
Michelangelo and Medici anchor the included tier as Firenze's two Main Dining Rooms — both Renaissance-styled, named for the Florentine master and the ruling dynasty respectively. Michelangelo is typically used for Your Time Dining and Medici for traditional assigned seating, though Carnival may adjust dining-room use by sailing. Neither carries a cover charge, and both are full-service, multi-course restaurants open to every guest. Both score 7.5, Included — Full Service.
Lido Marketplace (7.4) is the ship's buffet, open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner with no cover charge. Past the buffet, eight free quick-service stops give the included tier real depth — six shared with Venezia, plus two genuinely exclusive to this ship: Guy's Burger Joint (7.8), Guy Fieri's fleet-wide burger stand, carrying the same Italian-themed additions found on Venezia; Tomodoro (7.6), a Mexican-Italian fusion counter filling BlueIguana Cantina's usual slot; La Strada Grill (7.2), Italian street food served at sea-day lunch only; Il Mercato (7.4), Firenze's own deli/market counter, occupying the role Carnival Deli plays on Venezia; Pizzeria del Capitano (7.5), thin-crust pizza; Swirls (7.3), soft-serve; Fresh Creations (7.5), a made-to-order format genuinely exclusive to Firenze; and Chicken Shack (7.4), also genuinely exclusive to Firenze — it shares its operating counter with Seafood Shack rather than running as a fully separate physical restaurant.
Room Service (7.0) rounds out the included tier, running around the clock to every cabin. Continental breakfast remains complimentary; other room-service food selections are priced individually.
All 20 venues, explored
Every scored venue aboard Carnival Firenze, filterable — two more than sister ship Venezia, and this is exactly where the two ships' rosters genuinely diverge.
What are you in the mood to pay?
Every dining venue onboard, tagged, scored and sortable.
Twenty venues, twenty scores. See the “What's not aboard” section below for what's deliberately left off this list, and why.
Nothing matches that combination — try a different filter.
The same roster, plotted: what’s included, what costs extra, and how each venue actually scores.
Casual & extra cost
Three venues sit between the included tier and full specialty dining — the same three extra-cost casual venues carried by sister ship Venezia.
Seafood Shack (7.6) is an à la carte seafood counter — a lobster roll runs around $16, alongside fried baskets. It shares its physical operating counter with the included-tier Chicken Shack, one venue's space serving two distinct menus and pricing structures rather than two separate restaurants. Shake Spot (7.3) is an à la carte milkshake counter, with an alcoholic option on some selections. JavaBlue Cafe (7.4) is the ship's specialty coffee counter, running roughly $2-$6.50 per item.
All three are identical in name, format, and price to the versions aboard Venezia — the extra-cost casual tier is one of the few places the two Venice Class ships match exactly, alongside the specialty roster.
Specialty dining
Five specialty restaurants drive Firenze's 8.5 Specialty Dining score — the identical bench, at the identical score, carried by sister ship Venezia.
Il Viaggio (8.6) is a regional Italian tasting menu that replaces the Cucina del Capitano slot found on Carnival's other classes, priced at $50.40 per adult and $16.80 per child — that total price already includes Carnival's 20% service charge. Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse (8.8), reported as the largest Fahrenheit 555 in the fleet at 126 seats, runs $62.40 per adult and $18.00 per child, also with the 20% service charge already included in that total.
Bonsai Sushi (8.3) is an à la carte sushi bar. Bonsai Teppanyaki (8.6), reported as the largest teppanyaki room in the fleet at four tables, is priced differently from the three restaurants above: $49 per person, with Carnival's 20% service charge added separately at checkout, not folded into that $49. The Chef's Table (9.0) tops the roster at $148.80 per person, a total price that, like Il Viaggio and Fahrenheit 555, already includes the 20% service charge.
Pricing confirmed against Carnival's current reservation pages, August 2026. Specialty pricing can change between sailings — verify current specialty-dining pricing in the Carnival HUB app or onboard before you book.
Special experiences
Special Experiences is Firenze's single strongest category at 9.0 — carried almost entirely by one venue, and identical to Venezia's own 9.0.
The Chef's Table
A single-driver category, reinforced by an interactive second format
The Chef's Table single-handedly sets this category's 9.0 score — the same convention this project applies wherever one hosted experience effectively is the category. It's a multi-course tasting menu priced at $148.80 per person, service charge included. Bonsai Teppanyaki reinforces the category as a secondary interactive format — tableside cooking, knife work, and presentation for every guest, not a hosted-only experience limited to a handful of seats per sailing.
Special Experiences reads 9.0 because The Chef's Table genuinely earns that score on its own merits, and Bonsai Teppanyaki adds real depth behind it. This category, unlike Included Dining, Variety, Value, and Casual & Quick Dining, reads identically on both Venice Class ships.
Suite & restricted dining
A real, if modest, benefit — not a dedicated suite restaurant, and not an absence either.
Moda Lounge breakfast access
Morning-only, select menu, a lounge rather than a restaurant
Qualifying suite guests get morning access to the Moda Lounge for a daily select breakfast menu. That's a real, current, scoreable benefit — not nothing, and this guide doesn't erase it into an absence the way it would if no suite dining benefit existed at all. But it is not a dedicated suite restaurant: there's no lunch or dinner service, the menu is limited, and the space is a lounge rather than a restaurant.
That combination is why Suite & Restricted Dining scores 4.3 here — well below full suite-restaurant programs elsewhere in this project (Princess's Reserve Collection Dining scores 7.6; Celebrity's Luminae, Royal Caribbean's Coastal Kitchen, and Norwegian's Sanctuary-tier restaurants score higher still), but genuinely above a flat floor score, because there is something real here to evaluate.
Both Venice Class ships carry this exact 4.3 Suite & Restricted Dining score — Venezia's equivalent guests get the same breakfast-only benefit at the Carnevale Lounge. It's one of the four categories that read identically across the class.
What's not aboard — or not scored
A few things this guide deliberately leaves off Firenze's scored roster, and why.
Find your fit
Two questions, and a plan built for your sailing rather than everyone's.
What should you actually book?
Your dining personality changes what you should reserve first. Your sailing length changes how much of the 20-venue roster you can realistically work through.
What's your dining personality?
How many nights are you sailing?
Smart moves before you sail
Michelangelo and Medici are both yours, every night
Michelangelo is typically used for Your Time Dining and Medici for traditional assigned seating, though Carnival may adjust dining-room use by sailing. Either way, both are full-service and complimentary.
Chicken Shack shares its counter with Seafood Shack
They're two distinct menus and pricing structures, but one physical space — don't expect a fully separate restaurant footprint.
Il Viaggio, Fahrenheit 555, and The Chef's Table already include the service charge
Their stated prices are the total you'll pay — Carnival's 20% service charge is folded in, not added at checkout.
Bonsai Teppanyaki's $49 gets a 20% charge added separately
Unlike the three specialty restaurants above, Teppanyaki's price is quoted before the service charge, which Carnival adds at checkout — budget for roughly $58.80 per person.
The Moda Lounge breakfast is a real perk, not a suite restaurant
Qualifying suite guests get morning access for a daily select menu — worth knowing about, but don't expect lunch or dinner service there.
Fresh Creations and Chicken Shack are the entire reason Firenze edges her sister
Along with Il Mercato, these extra complimentary venues are why Firenze's Seabound Dining Score reads 8.2 against Venezia's 7.9 — a real, modest 0.3-point gap, not a rounding artifact.
Firenze in her class
Carnival's second class in this project — a real, modest gap, not a tie
Carnival Firenze (2024) and Carnival Venezia (2023) are Carnival's Venice Class — both ex-Costa hulls (Costa Firenze and Costa Venezia) transferred into the Carnival fleet as the line's first-ever “transfer class,” built originally for a Costa China-market push that COVID canceled. They share an identical, genuinely distinctive specialty and premium program: Il Viaggio, Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, Bonsai Sushi, Bonsai Teppanyaki, and The Chef's Table, at identical scores, plus an identical Quality Ceiling, Special Experiences score, and Suite & Restricted Dining benefit. What they don't share is the included and casual tier: Firenze's extra complimentary venues — Fresh Creations, Chicken Shack, and Il Mercato — give her a genuinely deeper roster (20 venues against Venezia's 18), and that's the entire reason she scores 8.2 against Venezia's 7.9. This is a real, modest 0.3-point gap, not a rounding artifact and not a tie.
2024 · 20 venues, the deeper included/casual bench that carries her past her sister.
Sister shipCarnival Venezia · 7.92023 · 18 venues, the leaner of the two Venice Class dining programs.
Beyond diningCarnival Firenze, the shipCabins, itineraries and the rest of the ship — the full non-dining picture of Firenze.
Carnival Venice Class is Carnival's second class covered in this project — it joins the site's Princess, Celebrity, MSC, Norwegian, Disney, Royal Caribbean, Virgin Voyages, and Excel Class guides as its own ecosystem, not a ranked comparison against them.
Quick answers
Why does Carnival Firenze score higher than Carnival Venezia if they share the same specialty restaurants?
Because the two ships share an identical specialty and premium program but not an identical included and casual one. Il Viaggio, Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, Bonsai Sushi, Bonsai Teppanyaki, and The Chef's Table are the same five restaurants at the same scores on both ships, and Specialty Dining, Quality Ceiling, Special Experiences, and Suite & Restricted Dining all read identically too. Firenze's edge is entirely in Included Dining, Variety, Value, and Casual & Quick Dining, where her extra complimentary venues — Fresh Creations, Chicken Shack, and Il Mercato — give her a genuinely deeper roster than Venezia's. That's a real, modest gap (8.2 versus 7.9, weighted 8.155 versus 7.940), not a rounding artifact and not a tie.
Does Carnival Firenze have one main dining room or two?
She has two, and both are complimentary. Michelangelo is typically used for Your Time Dining and Medici for traditional assigned seating, though Carnival may adjust dining-room use by sailing. Both are full-service, multi-course, no-cover-charge restaurants regardless of which seating style is running in which room.
Is Chicken Shack a separate restaurant from Seafood Shack on Carnival Firenze?
No — they share the same physical operating counter. Chicken Shack is a genuinely Firenze-only complimentary venue, and Seafood Shack is Firenze's extra-cost casual seafood counter, but the two run from one shared space rather than two separate physical restaurants. This guide counts them as two distinct venues in the scored roster because they are two distinct menus and pricing structures, but never presents Chicken Shack as occupying its own separate physical footprint.
Does Carnival Firenze have a suite or restricted dining restaurant?
Not a dedicated one. Qualifying suite guests (Terrazza and Ocean Suite categories) get morning access to the Moda Lounge for a daily select breakfast menu — a real, current benefit, but a breakfast-only lounge service, not a lunch-and-dinner suite restaurant. That's why Suite & Restricted Dining scores 4.3 here rather than the flat 1.0 floor this project uses when no such benefit exists at all, and well below full suite-restaurant programs elsewhere in this project.
Is Captain's Pasta Bar aboard Carnival Firenze?
No. Captain's Pasta Bar appeared in earlier secondary research but is confirmed absent from Carnival's current dining inventory for this ship, and it is not part of Firenze's scored roster.
Does Carnival Firenze have Carnival Deli?
No. Il Mercato occupies that deli/market-slot role on Firenze instead, and this guide never lists both venues for this ship. Carnival Deli is specific to sister ship Carnival Venezia.
How does Bonsai Teppanyaki's price compare to Il Viaggio, Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, and The Chef's Table?
Differently, and it's worth knowing before you book. Il Viaggio ($50.40 adult / $16.80 child), Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse ($62.40 adult / $18.00 child), and The Chef's Table ($148.80 per person) all state a total price that already includes Carnival's 20% service charge. Bonsai Teppanyaki's $49 per person is quoted before that charge, which Carnival adds separately at checkout. Pricing confirmed against Carnival's current reservation pages, August 2026.
Planning your Carnival Firenze dining?
Tell us your sailing, your crew and what matters most — Il Viaggio, The Chef's Table, or how the two Main Dining Rooms work — and we’ll tell you what to book the moment your reservation window opens.
Tap a question or the button and an advisor will answer against current pricing before you book.